Design Features of the Language User (06-Oct-2003)
Design features refer to physiological characteristics that are
unique to humans
- The vocal-auditory channel
- the most widespread form of human communication; many languages have
no writing system, but all make use of the vocal-auditory channel
- acquired first (individuals learn how to speak before they learn how
to write, and cultures don't develop written forms of language until after
they've developed spoken forms)
- written language skills are more fragile and vulnerable than
speaking/listening skills in the case of brain trauma: it is as if written
language is overlayed on top of vocal-auditory abilities (both in
individuals and in cultures)
- the vocal-auditory channel is supported by gaze: the sight line
between speaker and listener is important to the communication. Facial
expressions affect the message that's received. In evolutionary terms,
telephones are extremely recent developments, and are already starting to
develop video capabilities, which may suggest that peoples have a desire
(perhaps unconscious) to maintain the sight line in a conversation
- the vocal-auditory channel is supported by gesture. Some gestures are
culturally specialised (e.g. mediterranean, asian), but it doesn't seem
that there are gestures which are language-specific.
Some gestures have no apparent connection with the emotion or
expression being conveyed; others may be more specific (e.g. drawing
pictures in the air with your hands)
- The sound and nuances of expression in voice can convey information
additional to the spoken words, e.g. that the speaker is tired, angry,
drunk, etc..
- Biological foundations for language
- The physiological arrangements for speech seem to have been arrived at
by using bits of the anatomy that are there for other reasons, e.g. lungs,
windpipe, nose, tongue, oral cavity. See Crystal ch.22
- in humans, these organs appear to have evolved to make speech
possible. But this has disadvantages, e.g. humans occasionally choke on
food, whereas in lower primates the arrangement of the larynx makes it
almost impossible to do so.
- The epiglottis, which is like a valve which prevents foreign bodies
getting into the lungs, is positioned differently in primates than in
humans. In primates, when the epiglottis is closed, it shuts off the path
to the mouth, leaving an open path to the nose. In humans, the part of
the vocal tract above the epiglottis (the pharynx), is common to both
mouth and nose, and so although it acts as a valve above the larynx, it is
a lot less effective in preventing foreign bodies entering the lungs.
See Trask p.15
- The descent of the larynx
- It's hard to tell from fossil evidence (since most of the speech
organs are soft and don't fossilize well), but evidence suggests that
Neanderthal and Rhodesian man share the same "one-tube" system as today's
primates: efficient for non-vocal functions but not for speaking.
- Modern man has a "two-tube" system: the pharynx being at right angles
to the oral cavity. This is much more efficient at producing easily
distinguishable sounds ("ooo", "aaa" etc.)
- Humans are born having a "one-tube" system, which means that they
cannot make very many different vocal sounds, but that they are at much
lower risk of choking. The "descent of the larynx" takes place between 3
and 6 months, when the vocal tract becomes longer and assumes its
characteristically human proportions. As a result of this, there is a
change in voice quality (and increased danger of choking).
- The descent of language?
- Historical linguistics attempts to answer the question: are
different languages related to each other?
- The earlist reconstructed language we have is Proto-Indo-European
which is thought to have been spoken before 3000BC (see Crystal
p288)
- Most languages in the world are not descended from PIE
- It is conceivable that all languages are descended from a single
common ancestor (long since lost), or that there were multiple unrelated
languages which developed independently, which serve as the ancestors for
the languages we now know
- Cerebral specialisation
- The limbic system is the name given to a relatively primitive part
of the brain (developed around 100 million years ago), and is common to most
mammals, including humans
- The cerebral cortex developed around 2 million years ago, but only
in some mammals
- Generally speaking, the limbic system is associated for the visceral
muscles, such as stomach, heart, which move involuntarily. These also include
movements such as sneezing, coughing, laughing
- The cerebral cortex is more associated with skeletal muscles, that
is those which we "decide" to move, such as arms, legs, etc..
- Noises which are produced under stressful, or emotional conditions, such
as cries or calls are thought to be associated with the limbic system
- It is suggested that the noises produced by animals, such as a warning cry
when a predator appears, are precursors to language, although it's difficult
to say whether they are equivalent to "words" - does a particular cry
represent the word for "lion", or "hide"?
- Unlike such primitive sounds, human language is voluntary, patterned, and
structured into syllables; it is thought to be a function of the more highly
developed cortex.
- The boundary between "emotional" and "cognitive" is blurred though; and
examples such as "bouba/kiki" suggest that there may be a link between the
limbic/cortex - although it's difficult to argue that all words have
some primitive emotional significance
Language in the Individual and in
Society notes index